Desktop Apps versus Online Apps: What to Choose for Your Project

by Celine Roque

Since it’s rare to find a perfect tool that applies to all projects, the best you can do is look at your needs and strike a balance between desktop and online applications. But as you’re going through the phases of project development, how do you know which is the way to go?

Planning. This mostly depends on how your team prefers to conduct planning and brainstorming sessions. If you only do it in a meeting room with all members present, a desktop application is best. It’s usually just one file (or a few) that only one or two project administrators can access and edit. If your business computers are networked locally and the project files should only be accessed via office computers, you can use the local network as an alternative to the collaboration that online apps provide.

However, if some project plans require further collaboration after meetings or after office hours, online applications are the better option. It’s best to choose a user-friendly application that all participants can access via individual accounts. This is because most online collaborative software can track which changes were made by each member or who opened the document last. Alternatively, your tool of choice should allow email notifications sent to individual members or administrators whenever changes are made.

Executing. For projects that are primarily executed through writing, follow the same criteria as indicated in the planning stage. If it requires collaboration from different work environments, go for online. If not, go for desktop. However, design or graphics based projects are better developed via desktop apps. While Adobe recently launched an online version of Photoshop and Google Docs allows users to create and collaborate on presentations, the features of these online programs are limited compared to those available on their desktop counterparts.

If the project requires several documents that go hand in hand and should be edited or viewed by multiple team members, you can use your desktop applications with an online collaboration tool. Just make sure that a file upload feature is included, and that you can set custom security and privacy settings for each member. Some noteworthy online collaboration apps include Basecamp and Wrike.

Overall, your primary concern should be about how static or dynamic your project phases are going to be. The more modifications and changes you make along the way, the more you should lean towards using online applications. However, if you are going through a static project phase and you need to access files even without an internet connection, desktop applications are the way to go.

Share:
These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • e-mail
  • TwitThis
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • SphereIt
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Wists
  • Pownce


1 Comment »

  James wrote @ August 1st, 2008 at 3:49 pm

Hi Celine, great article. I wrote a similar article on this subject for a project management software blog (SantexQ Blog) and your explanation of it is very clear and informative. good job. would you mind if i linked to you? email me and let me know, thanks!

Your comment

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>


Connected services strategy for small business
Check out this ZD Net article by Larry Dignan - Microsoft talks software plus services; Intuit actually does it - or our recent press release for more on our future direction.
Check out Appopedia, a new section of The AppGap we've just launched that pulls together the scores of app reviews we've published here since we launched. Appopedia organizes the reviews into a useful directory that breaks down the tools by category and function. Check it out here.

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for our Email Newsletter

Recent Comments

  • Shiv Singh: Interesting model Matt and it looks like a lot of great thinking has gone into it. I’m not sure if...
  • Shiv Singh: I found your comments very interesting and I suspect that one factor at play is that it is harder for...
  • Matthew Hodgson: Some more thinking on this adoption model:
  • Victoria Axelrod: Models which continue to separate the personal from the organizational have an inherent flaw....
  • Hylton Jolliffe: Anita, Martin, Amanda, Cale, Mary, et al., As I posted just now we’ve launched the reviews...
The AppGap is a blog and resource on the future of work and how new tools are addressing age-old challenges of organization, collaboration, and innovation. But it is also an idea: that there remains a gap between the toolset that exists and what's needed... More about us.

About | Contributor Bios | Blog Policy | Contact us